CS CARES Committee

 

CARES Mission Statement
The Illinois CARES Committee was established to enable a climate in the Siebel School of Computing and Data Science that adheres to the school's Values and Code of Conduct. CARES provides a confidential resource to the SSCDS community, independent of the school administration, to (1) provide a friendly sounding board for concerns relating to the interpretation and violation of the SSCDS Values and Code of Conduct, (2) provide consultation for mechanisms to address such concerns, and (3) advocate and mediate on behalf of community members with such concerns, where appropriate. 

Purpose
All members of the Siebel School of Computing and Data Science at Illinois - faculty, staff, and students - are expected to adhere to the SSCDS Values and Code of Conduct (referred to as the Code below). The school and university administration provide many committees and mechanisms to uphold this Code. There are, however, situations where these mechanisms may be unclear and/or engaging with such a committee may be too intimidating. 

The role of CARES is to serve as a resource consisting of members of our community who are approachable and willing to listen to and help people who are concerned about or experience a potential violation of the Code. The committee members can be a sounding board for such concerns and can provide advice on the next steps to address the concerns. Such steps may range from a conversation among all parties (possibly informally mediated by CARES members) to a report filed to the appropriate department or university committee seeking an official action or response. At the request of the complainant and if appropriate, a CARES committee member may serve as an advocate on behalf of the complainant, including filing necessary reports and attending hearings with the complainant or on their behalf.  

We must emphasize that the CARES committee cannot undertake any official investigations or enforce sanctions. CARES committee members are also not trained to provide mental health counseling. The committee must obey all the rules of the University of Illinois, Grainger College of Engineering, and the Siebel School of Computing and Data Science, including the stipulations of Title IX. 

The motivation in providing a standing CARES committee is: (1) people are more likely to report violations of the Code if familiar and trusted members of the community are explicitly available for confidential consultation and support, (2) providing an explicit resource to discuss such matters may, in some cases, encourage earlier reporting, when it is easier to find mitigation, (3) an established committee with significant length membership terms enables building experience and a record that inspires more trust for those considering coming forward about violations, (4) committee members are expected to be visible and available to the community through various channels such as office hours and frequently monitored electronic media, and (5) the presence of such a committee assigned specifically to uphold the Code should serve as a deterrent for violations of the Code as well as encourage us all to be aware of it, uphold it, and speak up if we observe violations. 

Governance Policies
Although CARES is a committee of the Siebel School of Computing and Data Science, it operates independently of school administration, like the current Executive Committee. The autonomous operation is to increase the trust of all community members and affirm that CS CARES commits to offer support only in the best interests of the people who report concerns. CARES governance seeks to strike a balance in acknowledging the need for such autonomy, while also the need for support and stewardship by the school. 
 

Committee Structure
The CARES committee will consist of a chair, a vice-chair, a past chair, and several committee members. There must be at least: two faculty members from each of the three tenure-track levels (assistant, associate, full); two members from the specialized faculty; two staff members; one graduate student; and one undergraduate student. The committee must represent, to the extent possible, the diversity of the SSCDS community, including, but not restricted to, gender, ethnicity, and race. 

To provide a tighter connection with the school's governance, one of the committee members (and preferably no more than one) is an elected member of the Executive Committee (chosen by consensus of the chairs of the CARES and the Executive Committees).  

A representative from the school’s human resources team will serve on the committee in an advisory role. 

It is usually expected that at the end of their term, the vice-chair will be the new chair of the committee, and the current chair will serve as the past chair. The vice-chair is therefore expected to play an active role in the committee during their term, and the past chair is expected to primarily play an advisory role. 

Committee members normally are invited to serve a 2-year term, with a maximum of 6 years served consecutively, and a minimum of 4 years away from the committee before serving again.  Committee members who serve as vice-chair, chair, or past chair may serve longer in these positions. 

Committee Member Appointments
The members of the CARES Committee are chosen largely for their commitment and record on the issues covered by the Code. Because of the gravity and personal nature of the issues that may appear before this committee, ensuring committee members are empathetic, trustworthy, and discreet is of the utmost importance.  

At the end of each academic year, the school will solicit recommendations for new members of the CARES committee from different constituents (faculty, staff, and students) and convey them to the current CARES chair. The CARES committee will vet these recommendations (e.g., with the past committee chair, student organization representatives, and collaborators of the nominee) and prepare a final candidate list by consensus. The CARES chair will convey this list to the Director of the school. The Director will invite new members from this list, balancing other faculty’s loads and CARES’ diversity considerations. There is no maximum limit on the number of members on the committee. 

At the end of each academic year, the CARES chair, vice-chair, and past chair will review the service of each committee member that has completed their two-year term and if a renewal for another term is appropriate, add them to the list submitted to the school director above. It is intended that members will desire to renew their terms at least once, with the goal of rotating no more than a quarter of the committee each year (of course, this is unlikely for undergraduates). 

The chair must be a tenured professor at the school. At the cadence of every two years, in the summer in which their terms expire, the chair and vice-chair nominate (one or two) candidates for the next vice-chair (from the committee membership for the subsequent year). The vice-chair and chair seek input on these nominations from the rest of the committee for the current year and from the chair of the Advisory committee to make the final decision on the new vice-chair. 

A committee member may be removed from the committee by consensus of the chair and vice-chair if any problems arise (e.g., breach of confidence). The school director is informed of the removal, but confidentiality reasons may not permit sharing the reasons for removal. Removal of the vice-chair must occur in consultation with the approval of the chair of the Advisory Committee. If problems arise with the chair, then at the petition of more than half the members of the CARES committee, the chair of the Advisory committee may consider removal and replacement of the chair. 

Committee Member Responsibilities
CARES committee members are expected to contribute equally to achieve the below goals for CARES.

  • Availability: CARES holds at least one in-person or zoom “walk-in” office hour each weekday and provides an email account and phone number that is monitored frequently.  
  • Events: CARES aims to provide representatives to attend most large SSCDS events so that any concerns that may arise during such events can be brought to immediate attention. CARES representatives announce their presence at these events.  
  • Support: CARES supports community members in addressing concerns about violations of the Code in ways described in the “Purpose” section of this document, while respecting the ethics, confidentiality, and conflicts of interest rules described in the next section. 
  • Outreach: CARES conducts outreach to make the SSCDS community aware of the Code and the role of CARES in enabling the community to uphold the Code.  

The initial CARES committees will also be responsible for the evolution of various aspects of CARES operations. For example, using a confidential file sharing forum to archive confidential CARES records. 

It is expected that the school, college, and/or university will make training materials available to CARES members in the future. CARES members are expected to complete all such training as these materials become available. 

Ethics, Confidentiality, and Conflicts of Interest
Committee members are held to the highest standards of conduct and discretion.
They must abide by all pertinent rules of the University of Illinois and of Title IX.  
 

All concerns brought to CARES members are treated with utmost confidentiality outside of CARES, unless permitted by the person raising the concern. By default, all concerns are conveyed to the CARES chair and the vice-chair, who use their discretion and determination of conflicts of interest (see below) to determine a (preferably minimal) subset of the committee with whom to share the concern. The community member raising the concern may explicitly request that it not be shared with certain members of the CARES committee. 

If a violation of the Code is reported against a committee member, the member is recused from CARES activities until a decision on the credibility of the report can be made. An official investigation that finds such a report to be credible results in the removal of the member from CARES.  

If a CARES committee member has a conflict of interest with the person against whom a concern is reported to them (e.g., advisor/advisee, collaborator, close colleague, etc.), the committee member will immediately refer the reporter to another committee member. A committee member with a conflict of interest on a concern cannot participate in any discussion related to the concern. 

Reporting to and oversight by SSCDS
Although CARES will work autonomously, the final responsibility for its appropriate functioning rests with the school. The CARES chair will submit an annual report to the chair of the Advisory Committee. Individual reports of concerns and conversations with committee members are unequivocally private.  The goal of the CARES report is to summarize the nature and scale of climate-related concerns within the school, but without inappropriate or confidential details. The CARES and Advisory committee chairs will discuss this report with the school director with the goal of further surveying the school climate, discussing mechanisms to improve the climate, and providing training materials to CARES and community members, as deemed necessary. 

Acknowledgements: The CARES committee idea and this document draw heavily from the SIGARCH/SIGMICRO CARES committee concept and its bylaws and the position of the faculty ombudsperson at the College of Engineering at the Texas A&M University.